Dominic Aaron Reynolds arrested on felony theft warrant after Lycoming Township disturbance

Lycoming Regional Police arrested 28-year-old Dominic Aaron Reynolds on September 18, 2026, following a disturbance involving threats and a reported weapon at a Lycoming Township residence. Reynolds was wanted on a felony theft warrant alleging he stole a firearm belonging to his brother, Levi Johnson — who was charged in August after allegedly shooting Reynolds in the chest during a separate disturbance. Units from SWPD located Reynolds’ vehicle, conducted a high-risk stop on Beauty’s Run Road, and took him into custody without incident; he was committed to Lycoming County Prison on $10,000 straight bail. Eddie Johnson Jr., another brother, was also taken into custody at the home on an unrelated Pennsylvania State Police warrant.