Middletown police arrest log — week ending Sept. 17, 2026
Arrests reported for a range of offenses — from disorderly conduct and DUI to arson and strangulation — plus six false alarms at a local business.
The Middletown Borough Police Department published its arrest log for the week ending Sept. 17, 2026, listing arrests tied to offenses including disorderly conduct, harassment, public drunkenness, strangulation, indecent assault, terroristic threats, DUI, arson, theft by deception and criminal mischief. Named individuals include Lakin Shetter, Ashley Brittelli, Anna Guiterrez, Jeremy Lopez, William Lighty, Bret Overcash, Darryl Fontenelle, Tyrel Fry, David Reeves, Ashley Bailey, Jeffrey Davis, Jordan Mayberry and Zachary Smith, with dates and locations noted for each incident. The log also records six false alarm responses over a 12-month period to 26 S Union St, the home of Mid Penn Games.